Thought of the day

eden

“The Eden story is certainly not a morality tale; like any paradise myth, it is an imaginary account of the infancy of the human race. In Eden, Adam and Eve are still in the womb; they have to grow up, and the snake is there to guide them through the perplexing rite of passage to maturity. To know pain and to be conscious of desire and mortality are inescapable components of human experience, but they are also symptoms of that sense of estrangement from the fullness of being that inspires the nostalgia for paradise lost. We can see Adam, Eve, and the serpent as representing different facets of our humanity. In the snake is the rebelliousness and incessant compulsion to question everything that is crucial to human progress; in Eve we see our hunger for knowledge, our desire to experiment, and our longing for a life free of inhibition. Adam, a rather passive figure, displays our reluctance take responsibility for our own actions. The story shows that good and evil are inextricably intertwined in human life. Our prodigious knowledge can at one and the same time be a source of benefit and the cause of immense harm. The rabbis of the Talmudic age understood this perfectly. They did not see the “fall” of Adam as a catastrophe, because the “evil inclination” (yeytzer ha’ra) was an essential part of human life, and the aggression, competitive edge, and ambition that it generates are bound up with some of our greatest achievements.”

Karen Armstong - The Case for God

4 Responses to “Thought of the day”
jennifer Posted on December 3, 2009 at 5:28 pm

“…like any paradise myth, it is an imaginary account of the infancy of the human race.”

Ms. Armstrong made some great points. I think there is so much symbolism is the Bible – there’s always something new for God to reveal to us as we study (the Temple is a great example).

But I think if you begin reading the Bible using the words myth and imaginary account to describe Genesis, you have at the least trivialized the entire Bible and at worst, attempted to compromise its validity. If you go from “In the beginning GOD”… to a ‘mythological account’ of His placing Adam in the garden… that’s major conflict.

Yep. You made me think!

Glad to hear from you Archie.

Phill Grooms Posted on December 4, 2009 at 8:10 am

I like it. Thanks.

Jana Posted on December 4, 2009 at 8:57 am

Sounds like she’s saying that the fall of man was supposed to happen, with the “guidance” of the snake. Sorry, don’t believe that for a minute. Sounds like heresy. :) I believe God never intended for us to live with pain and go thru hardships in life… The sending of Christ was to redeem us from that b/c Adam and Eve BOTH gave in to temptation. And to say that Adam represents a reluctance to take responsibility simply adds to the notion that men nowadays are portrayed as weak and stupid (Have you seen husband-wife commercials lately?).

Archie – love your posts, but this one ranks the lowest with me. :)

Archie Posted on December 4, 2009 at 9:11 am

Jana- The post was just to make you think about the narrative, nothing more.

Post a Comment